Patients, Voters and Courts: The Legalization Era, 1990 to Now
Patients, voters and courts took the plant from Schedule I to a legal market in dozens of places, and this is Part 5 of 6 in "Cannabis Through the Ages."
The prohibition century wasn't undone by one law. It came apart piece by piece: a brownie-baking hospital volunteer in San Francisco, a ballot measure in California, a decriminalization law in Lisbon, a store opening in Denver, a little girl with seizures on CNN, a UN vote decided by two countries. This is how the plant went from Schedule I to a $27 billion American market, and why the fight still isn't over.
The science changes
In 1992, Raphael Mechoulam's group, the same team that identified THC in 1964, found anandamide, a compound the human body makes on its own that acts on the same receptors as THC. Cannabis wasn't just a foreign substance anymore. It was hitting a system the body already used.
The establishment science caught up later. In January 2017, the National Academies of Sciences, Engineering, and Medicine reviewed more than 10,000 study abstracts and found conclusive or substantial evidence that cannabis helps chronic pain in adults, chemotherapy nausea and multiple sclerosis spasticity. It found no link between smoking marijuana and lung cancer and no substantial evidence that marijuana leads people to other illegal drugs, though it did tie regular smoking to bronchitis. Several of those findings repeated what the same academies had reported in 1999.
San Francisco and the AIDS crisis
The medical cannabis movement started in a city watching its young men die. Mary Jane Rathbun was a volunteer in the AIDS ward at San Francisco General Hospital, Ward 86, from 1984, and was named its volunteer of the year in 1986. She was better known as Brownie Mary. When police raided her home on January 14, 1981, they found more than 18 pounds of cannabis and 54 dozen brownies. She was arrested twice more, in 1982 and 1992, and acquitted the second time. On August 25, 1992, San Francisco declared Brownie Mary Day.
Her partner in the movement was Dennis Peron, whose own partner, Jonathan West, died of AIDS in 1990. On November 5, 1991, Peron organized Proposition P, a symbolic San Francisco resolution supporting medical cannabis, and it passed with 79% of the vote. Peron then opened the San Francisco Cannabis Buyers Club, often called the first public dispensary. In October 1996, a month before the statewide vote that would change everything, California's attorney general had Peron's club raided and Peron arrested.
Patients go first
On November 5, 1996, California voters passed Proposition 215, the Compassionate Use Act, 55.6% to 44.4%>). It protected patients and caregivers from state charges when a doctor recommended marijuana. Arizona passed a medical measure the same year, but it said "prescribe" instead of "recommend," which clashed with federal law and made it useless. California's was the first that worked. Peron's club reopened.
Washington, Oregon, Alaska and Nevada followed in 1998, Maine in 1999, and Colorado and Hawaii in 2000. Hawaii was the first to do it through the legislature instead of a ballot. Canada opened a federal medical program in 2001.
The federal government pushed back. In 2005, in Gonzales v. Raich, the Supreme Court ruled 6 to 3 that federal law could reach even homegrown medical marijuana that was legal under California law. Then, in October 2009, Deputy Attorney General David Ogden told federal prosecutors that going after patients who clearly followed state law generally wasn't a good use of resources. That memo wasn't law, but it gave states room.
The rest of the world experiments
Outside the US, change came through courts and health policy. Colombia's Constitutional Court protected a 20-gram personal dose in 1994. On July 1, 2001, Portugal decriminalized personal possession of all drugs, defined as up to a ten-day supply, or 25 grams of cannabis or 5 grams of hash, and turned it into an administrative matter handled by health-focused panels. Brazil dropped prison for personal possession in 2006, and Mexico decriminalized up to 5 grams in 2009. The Czech Republic decriminalized possession on January 1, 2010.
Glass on trial
In the early 2000s the federal government went after the pipe. On February 24, 2003, Attorney General John Ashcroft's Justice Department launched Operation Pipe Dreams, a roughly two-year, $12 million sting on glass pipe makers and sellers. Agents raided more than 100 homes and businesses in several states, and 55 people were indicted on paraphernalia charges. Among them was Jason Harris of Jerome Baker Designs, then the world's largest glass smokeware company.
The most famous defendant was Tommy Chong. His company, Chong Glass Works, employed about 25 glassblowers making about 100 pipes a day, and undercover agents pushed it to ship across state lines. On September 11, 2003, Chong was sentenced to nine months in federal prison, a $20,000 fine and forfeiture of $103,000. He was the only one of the defendants to serve prison time. The operation hurt hundreds of glass artists and did little to stop the trade, and the heady glass scene came back bigger than before.
Oaksterdam and the road to 2012
In November 2007, Richard Lee opened Oaksterdam University in Oakland. Its first classes had 22 students. In 2010, Lee put more than $1.3 million of his own money into Proposition 19, a California legalization measure. It failed with 46.5% of the vote, but it set the stage for what came next. Before dawn on April 2, 2012, federal agents raided Oaksterdam, its museum and Lee's apartment. No charges were ever filed, and classes resumed within 48 hours. Lee died in 2025 at 62.
On November 6, 2012, Colorado and Washington became the first places in the world to vote for legal adult-use cannabis, with 55.3% and 55.7% of the vote. In August 2013, the Justice Department's Cole memo set out eight federal priorities, like keeping cannabis away from kids and cartels, and signaled it would mostly leave state-legal markets alone.
On January 1, 2014, the first legal adult-use sales happened in Colorado, with a ceremonial first sale at 3-D Cannabis Center in Denver. Washington's first sale came on July 8, 2014, at 8 a.m. at Top Shelf Cannabis in Bellingham.
Uruguay beat both to the national level. On December 23, 2013, President José Mujica signed Law 19.172, making Uruguay the first country to fully legalize and regulate cannabis. Registered citizens can grow six plants at home, join a club, or buy up to 40 grams a month at a pharmacy, which started in 2017. Tourists can't buy. By the end of 2025, Uruguay had 83,567 registered pharmacy buyers, sold about 4,290 kilograms through pharmacies that year, and was studying whether to open sales to visitors.
Charlotte's Web
In 2013, CNN aired WEED, a documentary by Dr. Sanjay Gupta. It featured Charlotte Figi, a little girl with Dravet syndrome, a severe form of epilepsy. Her family said a high-CBD strain had nearly eliminated her seizures. The strain was bred by seven Stanley brothers and named Charlotte's Web after her. Gupta had been a skeptic of medical marijuana, and the film was widely seen as his turnaround. It changed the national conversation about CBD almost overnight. Charlotte died on April 7, 2020, at 13.
On June 25, 2018, the FDA approved Epidiolex, a CBD medicine from GW Research, for seizures from Lennox-Gastaut and Dravet syndromes. The approval was backed by three controlled trials with 516 patients.
The 2016 wave and the first legislatures
On November 8, 2016, voters legalized adult use in California (Proposition 64 passed 56% to 44%), Massachusetts, Nevada and, barely, Maine, 50.1% to 49.9%. Arizona said no that year. Florida, Arkansas, Montana and North Dakota passed medical measures. In January 2018, Vermont became the first state to legalize through its legislature instead of a ballot. Illinois became the first legislature to legalize with retail sales, signed June 25, 2019, with stores opening January 1, 2020.
New York decriminalized in 2019 and legalized on March 31, 2021, with a law built around repairing the damage of the arrest years. That story gets its own article tomorrow in Part 6.
The Caribbean, Africa and Asia move
Jamaica decriminalized two ounces or less in April 2015, allowed five plants per household, and exempted Rastafari sacramental use. Antigua and Barbuda, St Vincent and the Grenadines, St Kitts and Nevis, and Trinidad and Tobago followed between 2018 and 2020, and Antigua's prime minister publicly apologized to Rastafari for past persecution. Barbados passed a medical cannabis law and a Sacramental Cannabis Act in November 2019. In August 2018, a CARICOM regional commission published a report titled "Waiting to Exhale" urging the region to drop criminal penalties and move toward legal regulation. Not everyone in the region got to choose: in 2022, Britain had Bermuda's governor refuse assent to a cannabis licensing bill passed by Bermuda's own parliament.
Lesotho issued Africa's first medical cultivation licence in 2017, and Zimbabwe followed. On September 18, 2018, South Africa's Constitutional Court unanimously ruled that private adult use and growing were protected by the right to privacy. The case was led by Gareth Prince, a Rastafarian who had lost a religious-freedom case by one vote, 5 to 4, in 2002. In November 2018, South Korea became the first East Asian country to allow certain cannabinoid medicines. Thailand legalized medical cannabis in February 2019, the first in Southeast Asia. Israel decriminalized personal use in 2019, and Lebanon became the first Arab country to legalize medical and industrial growing in April 2020.
Canada and the hemp loophole
On October 17, 2018, Canada's Cannabis Act took effect, making it the second country after Uruguay to legalize, and the first G7 nation. Edibles followed in October 2019, capped at 10 milligrams of THC per package. A government-appointed expert panel reviewed the law in March 2024, made 54 recommendations, and found that possession charges had fallen 95% between 2017 and 2022. In the year ending March 31, 2025, Canadians bought about C$5.5 billion of legal cannabis, and governments collected about C$2.5 billion from it.
In the US, Attorney General Jeff Sessions rescinded the Cole memo in January 2018. But in December 2018, Congress passed the Farm Bill, which legalized hemp as cannabis with no more than 0.3% delta-9 THC. Because the law only counted delta-9, a whole intoxicating market grew out of the gap: delta-8 made from CBD, and THCA flower that tests under the limit until you light it. That gap shaped smoke shops for the next seven years.
In 2019, a lung illness called EVALI hit vapers across the country. By February 2020 the CDC counted 2,807 hospitalized cases or deaths and 68 deaths, and named vitamin E acetate as a primary cause.
The UN changes its mind, slightly
On December 2, 2020, the UN Commission on Narcotic Drugs voted 27 to 25, with one abstention, to remove cannabis and cannabis resin from Schedule IV of the 1961 treaty, its strictest category. The US voted yes and pointed to the FDA's approval of Epidiolex. Cannabis stayed under full international control in Schedule I, and the members rejected most of the WHO's other cannabis recommendations, but it was a small change on paper with a lot of symbolism.
Europe goes its own way
Morocco legalized medical, cosmetic and industrial cannabis in 2021. By June 2026, it reported more than 140 registered cannabis products and 5,765 active permits, and in August 2024 the king pardoned 4,831 cannabis farmers.
Malta became the first EU country to legalize, on December 14, 2021, allowing home growing and non-profit associations. Luxembourg allowed home growing in 2023. Germany legalized on April 1, 2024, with 25 grams in public, 50 at home and three plants, plus non-profit clubs from July. Its April 2026 government review found youth use stable and the share of users getting most of their cannabis from home growing up from 5.4% to 21.4%, while the clubs supplied at most 3.5% of users. A separate bill to end mail-order medical flower was still stuck in the Bundestag in mid-2026.
Others moved more cautiously. Ukraine's medical cannabis law took effect on August 16, 2024. The Netherlands launched the full phase of its regulated coffeeshop supply experiment on April 7, 2025, in ten cities. Spain approved hospital-only medical cannabis by royal decree in October 2025. Czechia amended its criminal code so that from January 1, 2026, adults can grow three plants and keep up to 100 grams at home, though there's still no legal market. A Swiss parliamentary committee released a draft adult-use law for consultation in August 2025. In May 2025, a commission set up by London Mayor Sadiq Khan recommended decriminalizing small amounts, and the Home Office said no. Italy went backward, using a 2025 security decree to ban hemp flower.
Asia swings both ways
Thailand made the sharpest swing anywhere. It removed cannabis from its narcotics list in June 2022, and by 2025 it had more than 11,200 approved dispensaries. In June 2025, the government made flower a controlled herb sold only with a paper prescription. On September 22, 2026, the cabinet approved a medical-only Cannabis Control bill under which shops that want to keep operating must become medical facilities with a doctor on the premises. As of late October 2026, it was still waiting for parliament.
Nepal's Gandaki Province legalized licensed medical and industrial growing in August 2026, even though the national ban still stands. Pakistan's cabinet approved its first national cannabis policy in January 2026 for medical and industrial use. India's Himachal Pradesh opened licensing for industrial hemp in 2025. Taiwan cut its penalties for growing cannabis for personal use in 2022.
Other governments held the line or tightened it. Hong Kong banned CBD outright on February 1, 2023. Japan, which had never made cannabis use itself a crime, did so on December 12, 2024, with up to seven years in prison. Malaysia ended its mandatory death penalty for drug trafficking in July 2023, though judges can still impose it. Singapore kept hanging people for cannabis: Tangaraju Suppiah was executed on April 26, 2023, over about a kilogram, and Omar bin Yacob Bamadhaj on April 16, 2026. In the Philippines, House committees approved a medical cannabis bill in February 2026. In Australia, medical cannabis prescriptions grew from about 17,000 in 2020 to more than 800,000 in 2024.
Africa and Latin America build slowly
Across Africa, the shift has been toward licensed medical and export farming. Zambia passed a Cannabis Act and an Industrial Hemp Act in May 2021, and Rwanda set rules for medical cannabis production in June 2021. Malawi issued 86 licences to 35 organizations in April 2021. Uganda licensed a medical cannabis farm in July 2025. Ghana's Supreme Court struck down its first licensing provision in 2022, Parliament rewrote it in 2023, and the government finally opened applications for medical and industrial licences in early 2026.
South Africa's 2024 Cannabis for Private Purposes Act was signed on May 28, 2024, but it still wasn't fully in operation by late 2026. Draft rules published in February 2026 would allow up to 750 grams per adult and five plants. Sale is still illegal. In Kenya, a High Court judge rejected a Rastafari petition for religious use on July 15, 2026, while calling the current situation untenable.
In Latin America, the courts keep moving faster than the legislatures. Mexico's Supreme Court struck down the adult-use ban in June 2021, but Congress never built a market. President Claudia Sheinbaum said in 2025 that everything is up for discussion but legalization has many complexities, and in July 2026 the federal health regulator repeated that sales remain illegal. Brazil's Supreme Court decriminalized up to 40 grams or six plants in June 2024. Two months earlier, Brazil's Senate had passed a constitutional amendment to criminalize possession of any amount, and it was still pending in the lower house. Brazil's Superior Court of Justice cleared licensed medical hemp growing in November 2024, and new national cultivation rules took effect in August 2026. Argentina's Milei government tightened the country's medical registry in 2024 and 2025. The Bahamas passed medical and religious cannabis laws in 2024, though the system wasn't yet dispensing.
Some places vote no
New Zealand rejected legalization in October 2020, 50.7% to 48.4%. Florida's 2024 measure got about 56%, short of the 60% it needed. And on November 3, 2026, Massachusetts voters rejected Question 8, which would have repealed adult-use sales starting in 2028. A September poll found 71% opposed to the repeal. On election night it lost about 75.6% to 24.4%.
Washington, finally
The first federal crack came through the budget. On May 29, 2014, the House voted 219 to 189, with 49 Republicans on board, to bar the Justice Department, including the DEA, from spending money to interfere with state medical marijuana laws. The Rohrabacher-Farr amendment made it into the spending bill Congress passed that December. It's the same tool Congress uses to stop D.C. from selling weed, a rider in a spending bill, just pointed the other way.
The federal story moved slowly, then suddenly. On October 6, 2022, President Joe Biden pardoned federal and D.C. simple-possession convictions and ordered a review of marijuana's schedule. In August 2023, HHS recommended Schedule III. The DEA proposed it in May 2024 and drew more than 42,000 comments, but its hearing was suspended in January 2025.
In December 2025, President Donald Trump signed an executive order directing the attorney general to finish Schedule III rulemaking. On April 23, 2026, the Justice Department announced that marijuana in FDA-approved drugs and marijuana sold under a state medical license would move to Schedule III, effective April 28. Adult-use marijuana is still Schedule I. A new hearing on moving all of it ran from June 29 to July 15, 2026, where the FDA testified that marijuana has accepted medical uses. In October 2026, the judge refused to reopen the hearing; final reply briefs were filed November 5. A final decision is still pending.
Hemp went the other direction. In November 2025, Congress rewrote the federal hemp definition to count total THC, including THCA, and to exclude finished products with more than 0.4 milligrams of THC per container. In September 2026, the THC caps were pushed to December 11, 2026, while a ban on synthetic cannabinoids still takes effect November 12, 2026. The SAFE Banking Act was refiled in June 2026. It has never passed the Senate.
The legal industry is huge and stressed at the same time. One tally of state data put 2025 US legal sales at about $27 billion. Big multi-state operators have watched their stock prices fall sharply and fought the IRS over 280E, the tax rule that blocks normal business deductions for plant-touching companies. As of October 2026, 24 states allow adult use and 41 allow medical use, according to the Marijuana Policy Project.
What the whole story tells us
Cannabis spent about ten thousand years as a crop, a medicine and a sacrament before anyone tried to ban it. The bans started small and specific, almost always aimed at a group someone in power was nervous about. In 1925 they went global, and by 1970 the plant was officially worthless in the eyes of the US government. Every serious study along the way, in Calcutta in 1894, in New York in 1944, in London in 1969, in Washington in 1972 and in a DEA courtroom in 1988, said the laws were out of proportion. It took patients, voters and courts, not governments, to start changing them.
We're not at the end. We're in the messy middle, with half-legal markets, shifting federal rules and some countries moving backward. But the direction since 1996 has been clear. Tomorrow, in Part 6, we bring it home and tell the whole story through New York.
Sources
- Marijuana Herald: US legal cannabis sales near $27 billion in 2025 (2026)
- IACM: Raphael Mechoulam profile
- Cannabis Business Times: National Academies report on cannabis health effects (2017)
- NCIA: House passes Rohrabacher-Farr amendment, 219-189 (2014)
- MPP: Congress passes medical marijuana amendment in spending bill (2014)
- Wikipedia: Brownie Mary
- Wikipedia: Dennis Peron (San Francisco Prop P, 1991)
- Ballotpedia: California Proposition 215 (1996)>)
- Wikipedia: Cannabis in Arizona (1996 Prop 200)
- Wikipedia: Medical cannabis in the United States
- Wikipedia: Cannabis in Hawaii
- Wikipedia: Cannabis in Canada
- Cornell LII: Gonzales v. Raich (2005)
- US Department of Justice: Ogden memo (2009)
- Dejusticia: 30 years of Colombian drug decriminalization (2024)
- BMJ: Portugal's drug decriminalization
- Wikipedia: Cannabis in Portugal
- Wikipedia: Cannabis in Brazil
- Wikipedia: Cannabis in Mexico
- Wikipedia: Cannabis in the Czech Republic
- World of Cannabis Museum: Operation Pipe Dreams
- NORML: Operation Pipe Dreams, 55 indicted (2003)
- Wikipedia: Operation Pipe Dreams
- Wikipedia: Oaksterdam University
- Boston Globe: Richard Lee obituary (2025)
- Oaksterdam University: The raid
- Brookings: Comparing legal marijuana laws
- Mintz: Sessions memo and the Cole memo (2018)
- Washington Times: first legal sales in Colorado (2014)
- KNKX: Bellingham store first to sell legal pot in Washington (2014)
- Wikipedia: Cannabis in Uruguay
- Sechat: Uruguay cannabis sales hit record (2025)
- Westword: Charlotte Figi dies at 13 (2020)
- Drugs.com: FDA approves Epidiolex (2018)
- MG Retailer: 2016 cannabis ballot initiatives
- Wikipedia: Legality of cannabis by U.S. jurisdiction
- NORML: New York governor signs legalization (2021)
- Jamaica Ministry of Justice: Dangerous Drugs Act fact sheet
- Jamaica Observer: Rastafari gain sacramental rights in Antigua and Barbuda (2023)
- CIJN: Legislation and decriminalisation in the Caribbean
- IDPC: CARICOM commission report, Waiting to Exhale (2018)
- Government of Bermuda: Attorney General on cannabis legislation (2022)
- Duvall: Cannabis in Africa (2019)
- Oxford Human Rights Hub: South Africa decriminalises private cannabis use (2018)
- NextShark: South Korea medical cannabis (2018)
- LawPlus: Thai law on medical cannabis (2019)
- Wikipedia: Cannabis in Israel
- Al Jazeera: Lebanon MPs meet (2020)
- Health Canada: Legislative review of the Cannabis Act (2024)
- Statistics Canada: Canada's cannabis business since legalization
- Wikipedia: Agriculture Improvement Act of 2018
- CDC: EVALI cases and deaths (2020)
- NPR: UN commission removes cannabis from strictest list (2020)
- CMS: Cannabis legal roadmap, Morocco
- Morocco World News: ANRAC director on therapeutic cannabis products (2026)
- IDPC: King of Morocco pardons cannabis farmers (2024)
- Euronews: Malta set to be first EU country to legalise cannabis (2021)
- Chronicle.lu: Luxembourg legalises domestic cultivation (2023)
- Bundestag: Cannabis Act (2024)
- Newsweed: EKOCAN report on German legalization (2026)
- GrowerIQ: Germany medical cannabis prescription reform (2026)
- UNN: Ukraine medical cannabis law in force (2024)
- Government of the Netherlands: Coffee shop experiment (2024)
- Cuatrecasas: Medicinal cannabis in Spain (2025)
- Expats.cz: Czech criminal code reform (2025)
- Bluewin: Swiss commission opens consultation on cannabis legalization (2025)
- London Drugs Commission (2025)
- Il Sole 24 Ore: Italy's security decree and cannabis light (2025)
- Tilleke & Gibbins: Thailand removes cannabis from the narcotics list (2022)
- Wikipedia: Cannabis in Thailand
- Tilleke & Gibbins: Thailand's new cannabis controls (2025)
- Forbes: Thailand cabinet approves medical-only cannabis bill (2026)
- Nation Thailand: Cabinet approves Cannabis Control bill (2026)
- Kathmandu Post: Gandaki pushes marijuana law through (2026)
- Express Tribune: Cabinet okays Pakistan cannabis policy (2026)
- HempToday: Himachal Pradesh opens hemp licensing (2025)
- Taipei Times: Taiwan cuts personal-grow penalties (2022)
- Wikipedia: Cannabidiol (Hong Kong CBD ban)
- Nippon.com: Japan cannabis use law (2024)
- Human Rights Watch: Malaysia repeals mandatory death penalty (2023)
- Death Penalty Information Center: Singapore executes man for cannabis importation (2023)
- Must Share News: Man executed for importing cannabis (2026)
- ABS-CBN: House panels approve medical cannabis bill (2026)
- SBS: Red flags amid Australia's medicinal cannabis rise
- Library of Congress: Zambia Cannabis Act and Industrial Hemp Act (2021)
- KT Press: Rwanda medical cannabis law (2021)
- Maravi Express: Malawi licences 35 organizations (2021)
- Daily Monitor: Uganda licenses farm to grow marijuana (2025)
- Graphic Online: Ghana Supreme Court on cannabis licensing (2022)
- Graphic Online: Interior minister can grant cannabis cultivation licences (2023)
- MyJoyOnline: Interior minister launches medicinal cannabis licensing (2026)
- South African Government: President assents to Cannabis for Private Purposes Bill (2024)
- EWN: Draft rules on South Africa's cannabis (2026)
- Africanews: Kenyan court rejects Rastafari cannabis bid (2026)
- Quadratin: Sheinbaum on marijuana (2025)
- Por Esto: COFEPRIS clarifies what the permit allows (2026)
- MercoPress: Brazil's STF sets 40-gram cap (2024)
- Agência Senado: Senate approves drug PEC (2024)
- Migalhas: STJ authorizes medical cannabis production (2024)
- Gazeta do Povo: New Anvisa cannabis cultivation rules take effect (2026)
- TalkingDrugs: Cannabis in Argentina
- Tribune 242: Bahamas cannabis laws (2024)
- New Zealand Electoral Commission: 2020 referendum results
- Wikipedia: Cannabis in Florida
- Weedmaps: Massachusetts repeal question and DEA delay (2026)
- NPR: Biden pardons marijuana possession convictions (2022)
- Federal Register: DEA proposed rule on Schedule III (2024)
- Moritz College of Law: Federal marijuana reform timeline 2022-26
- NORML: DEA judge stays scheduling proceedings (2025)
- Ropes & Gray: White House orders completion of marijuana rescheduling (2026)
- Federal Register: Schedule III order (April 28, 2026)
- Morgan Lewis: Post-DEA hearing, broader rescheduling questions (2026)
- NORML: DEA judge denies request to reopen hearing (2026)
- Akerman: Congress recriminalizes hemp-derived THC products (2025)
- Foley Hoag: A temporary reprieve for hemp THC products (2026)
- Forbes: Congress revives SAFE Banking bill (2026)
- Marijuana Policy Project: Key marijuana policy reform